When I saw Glenn Reynolds' link to a post titled "Is it His Katrina Yet?," I assumed that it would be about the disastrous flooding in Nashville. Instead, it was about the oil spill. William A. Jacobson documents a horror story of "bungled permitting, delays in response, and understating the impact" and asks,
What will it take for it to be His Katrina? Waddaya think, Brownie?
Once I realized that Nashville flood was not the Katrina Professor Jacobson was talking about, I thought "How many Katrinas do we need?"
The answer, obviously, is that Obama will never have a real Katrina, no matter what happens or how incompetent his administration's response. That's because Katrina -- and all disasters -- can be blamed only on the right wing. If it's a natural disaster, it's from Global Warming, which is a result of uncontrolled corporate greed (or, as in the case of Katrina, right wing racist genocide.) If OTOH, it's a man-made disaster, it's also a result of uncontrolled corporate greed. (By definition, uncontrolled denotes right of center, and evil.)
As to government-created disasters, by definition they are impossible under liberal governments, because liberalism by definition is about helping people, not harming the environment or enabling corporate greed. Anything that goes wrong is because the right wing either set in motion the events that created it, or thwarted the liberal attempts to intervene.
From this analysis, it also follows that any disaster that might happen under this liberal administration had its roots in the failures of the previous administration, and was thus "inherited."
Thus, it is not Obama's Katrina. By definition such a thing is impossible.
posted by Eric on 05.16.10 at 01:00 PM
Comments
The shit that's hitting the fan now is the sum total of the past 40 years of federal ineptitude and dumbassery coupled with unchecked ::GREED:: executed by **both** sides of the political aisle. To couch it in terms of a "liberal" or a "conservative" issue is being obtuse.
The shit that's hitting the fan now is the sum total of the past 40 years of federal ineptitude and dumbassery coupled with unchecked ::GREED:: executed by **both** sides of the political aisle. To couch it in terms of a "liberal" or a "conservative" issue is being obtuse.