Justice is blind, while activists remain visually impaired

While I have nothing but sympathy for blind people, I think the recent decision by the D.C. Court of Appeal that U.S. currency discriminates against the blind sets common sense on its head. Jonathan Adler quotes from the opinion:

The current design of paper money springs from the world of the sighted. Upon casual inspection, anyone with good vision can readily discern the value of U.S. currency; yet even the most searching tactile examination will reveal no difference between a $100 bill and a $1 bill.
Howard Bashman notes, however, that the decision itself discriminates against the blind:
Unfortunately, today's ruling of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit likewise discriminates against the blind, who must depend on others to learn what it says. And the online version of the ruling discriminates against those without internet access.
How true.

WIthout electronic readers, blind people cannot read currency. But neither can they read anything that isn't in Braille. This includes daily newspapers, most books, packages of food in stores (as well as shelf labels, scales used to weigh produce) and even prices at the fuel pump. Nor can they read speedometers or odometers, taxi fare meters, and highway signs. Virtually everything related to shopping and driving (including all stores and highways) discriminate against the blind. For that matter, so do cars. And so do blogs, theaters, television sets, video games, and art museums. On Saturday I went to the Philadelphia Art Museum to see the Frida Kahlo exhibit, and I can assure readers (at least those of them who can read or audially scan these words), that no blind person could have seen it.

And what about pornography? To the blind, it's even more useless than currency, because unlike currency, there are no electronic readers to read it. And in view of the recent Supreme Court decision, I'm also wondering what's to put the blind on notice that they might be downloading kiddie porn (much less imaginary or virtual kiddie porn)?

blind_justitia.jpg

How blind can naked power be?

And what about guns? In light of a very clever Op-Ed by Michael Bloomberg in today's Inquirer (attempting to link the "virtue of independence" to gun control), I'm also thinking about whether blind people are being effectively denied their Second Amendment rights by the evil gun industry. Think about it. Suppose you are a blind gun owner, and you want to engage in target practice in furtherance of your right to keep and bear arms in self defense. The way most guns are designed and the way most ranges are set up, how in the hell are you supposed to hit the target? I realize that there are probably electronic pointing and aiming systems which might emit audio signals (like a beep tone when you're on target), but how many guns have them? How many ranges are set up to accommodate them?

Does Mayor Bloomberg know that the blind are being effectively disarmed by the gun industry? And suppose a burglar breaks into your house? Even if your gun were equipped with an audio-signaled siting device, what about the burglar?

And suppose the burglar was also blind. What would put him (or any other blind person) on notice that a gun was being pointed at him? Seen this way, blind people are being discriminated against whether they're pro-gun or anti-gun. They are being effectively deprived of their Second Amendment rights by not being able to use firearms, and from an anti-gun perspective, virtually all guns are unsafe in that they cannot be seen, and give no warning to the blind that they're being pointed at.

Surely, if money discriminates against the blind, so do guns.

So why isn't Bloomberg sounding the alarm? It seems to me that he's overlooking another brilliant tactic which might be used against the firearms industry.

And a lot of activists are overlooking this tactic. If the goal is to shut things down and cripple the economy (whoops, I just said a bad word), the opportunities abound. You'd think the activists have blinders on. (Whoops again.)

Come on, get with the program! Do the blind always have to lead the visually impaired?

posted by Eric on 05.21.08 at 09:04 AM





TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://classicalvalues.com/cgi-bin/pings.cgi/6713






Comments

Perhaps you are not aware that many other countries use watermarks that can be felt by the blind. During the papermaking process, subtly raised patterns are created that the blind can sense.

Given the time and effort invested in upgrading US bills - and making them less easily counterfeited - it's a pity this was overlooked.

Ben-David   ·  May 21, 2008 12:56 PM

Ben-David's point edges toward mine. Blindness is itself a limitation, and it can be difficult to structure reality to reduce that. Where we can do so easily, however, as in currency design, we should do what we can. As with suits that complain about McDonald's scalding people, if the required remedy is simply "put some signs on your cups," then I don't see that as a problem. Changes in currency design do not seem a particular inconvenience for the rest of us.(For the record, on that infamous McDonald's case, they had let the coffee get up to 180 degrees, which badly scalded the person through their clothing. The heat through the cup was what caused them to drop it. To receive coffee through the window at 120 degrees is in the realm of expected danger and inconvenience, for which customers have little right to complain. It's hot coffee, what did you expect? 180 degrees is something else again.)

Assistant Village Idiot   ·  May 21, 2008 01:11 PM

Watermarks are fine. I'd even go for Braille numbers on the bills. As long as they don't make all the bills different sizes, I'm cool.

John S.   ·  May 21, 2008 04:50 PM

Post a comment

You may use basic HTML for formatting.





Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)



May 2008
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
        1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31

ANCIENT (AND MODERN)
WORLD-WIDE CALENDAR


Search the Site


E-mail




Classics To Go

Classical Values PDA Link



Archives




Recent Entries



Links



Site Credits