|
September 03, 2007
"Out of the Hood" and "Down the Tubes"
Dale Carpenter noticed something that not only are very few bloggers are discussing, but neither are any of the prominent leftist commentators who would normally be expected to weigh in and inveigh on these things -- an almost casual insinuation of race by the officer who arrested Larry Craig, in his attempt to shame a confession out of him: Karsnia: . . . I don't disrespect you but I'm disrespected right now and I'm not trying to act like I have all kinds of power or anything, but you're sitting here lying to a police officer. . . .Carpenter points out that while the remark could be interpreted in different ways, he thinks it is "race-specific in a case that otherwise has no obvious racial dimension" and wonders why the officer would feel the need to do that: To shame Craig into telling the truth, the officer could have used a different example, like, "I expect this from some punk we get off the street."It's as if the officer assumed Craig would feel shame by being compared with a lying black criminal suspect: ....the officer may have expected that Craig would immediately understand the reference and be especially shamed by it as a law-abiding white person. "Not only were you engaged in this tawdry behavior but now you're acting like a black thug who lies to a police officer about it," he seems to be saying. I doubt the officer would have used the "hood" reference if he'd been talking to a suspect who was black. It simply wouldn't have worked against a black suspect, whether that suspect was from "the hood" or not. It would have backfired even if used against, say, a wealthy black lawyer in a business suit. Further, in the presence of a black person the officer would have been sensitized to using a racial reference. It only works as a shaming technique if it's one white person speaking to another, with no blacks around to object.I think it's obvious why there's no chorus of left-wing objections. I also think it's interesting in the context of what Karsnia said immediately afterward. From the transcript: LC: All right, you saw something that didn't happen.We are going down the tubes? And why? Not so much because a Senator is alleged to have signalled a willingness to have sex in a mensroom, but because he wouldn't agree with Officer Karsnia's version of the story. So this means Craig is first, like a guy out of the hood, and finally, (the last thing Karsnia says), this is why the country (the only meaning I can think might attach to the misused "we" pronoun) is "going down the tubes." I'd almost swear the officer was grandstanding a bit. You know, as if he imagined the real audience was larger than Larry Craig? And what about this earlier remark? You're gonna have to pay a fine and that will be it. Okay. I don't call media, I don't do any of that type of crap.Surely, the officer wouldn't lie to a suspect, would he? Wouldn't want to have this nice old country going down the tubes.... Forgive my cynicism, but I'm beginning to think that perhaps Larry Craig (regardless of his level of denial) might not have been as stupid as I initially thought he was (and perhaps Officer Karsnia knew he had a big, big prize, and what the implications were). I don't know whether Craig made any phone calls, but can you imagine what would be happening now on all the talk shows if this case was just beginning to wind its way through the preliminary stages of the Minneapolis misdemeanor trial calendar? Imagine the power of being a guy in Karsnia's position. It's none of anybody's business, but Wendy Reid Crisp, at FROM THE BACK PEW, points out that Officer Karsnia drives a really cool old hearse, and is soon to be featured in Law and Order. The hobbies of public servants are, of course, none of our business, but old Caddy is a beauty and an appropriate vehicle for hauling off Craig's political career....plus, it may be making a tv debut soon: rumors are already out there that the Craig case may become a "Law & Order" episode ...Hey it is a beauty! Perfect for cruisin' down the tubes in style! (A car that says "we will bury you"?) Seriously, I like the car. The officer has good taste. (Of course, the gas mileage must suck, but you can't have everything.) MORE: I'm tempted to say that this whole thing reminds me of the Roman games, but I can't. I mean, consider my position. Not only do I write a blog that looks suspciously soft on Rome, but I've already been accused of being a Mafia-supporting Democrat, and I might easily be accused of having sympathy for the Romans.... (So I've been self-censored. Immortal gods!) UPDATE: For God's sake, is there any limit to this "outing" nonsense? Via Glenn Reynolds, I read that John Aravosis is now claiming that Senator what's-his-name (as if it matters who it is this time) is gay, so it's probably another "hypocrisy" to allow him to go to Iraq in violation of Don't Ask Don't Tell. Sorry, but these people have become insane. They're as meddlesome as the most meddlesome 1950s vice officers. And they are most definitely the new McCarthyites. I'd say gay McCarthyites, except there's not much gay about what they're doing; I'm old enough to remember when the word "gay" involved sexual freedom. Nowadays, it's rapidly becoming code language for sexual tyranny and invasion of privacy. (I can remember when cranky old reactionary types used to complain that the word "gay" no longer meant "gay," and that a perfectly good word had been ruined by the new meaning. I disagreed, but I think it's ironic that they're now ruining the perfectly good word's once perfectly good new meaning!) These guys deserve to have someone like Joseph Welch come along and say, "Have you no sense of decency, sir? At long last, have you left no sense of decency?" In that regard, I'm delighted to see Arianna Huffington standing up for a little common sense: I'm no fan of Larry Craig. Indeed, I disagree with almost everything he stands for. And I'd much rather he not be in the United States Senate. But I'd also rather have had his exit be the result of his constituents voting on his ideas and policies, instead of a ridiculous sting operation in an airport bathroom.Such candor might not have quite the gravitas of Joseph Welch, but it's deeply refreshing. posted by Eric on 09.03.07 at 09:21 AM
Comments
Your theory may have merit, but I don't think it's a fit with the official script. Eric Scheie · September 3, 2007 05:17 PM Prediction: Several years from now, Officer Karsnia will be testifying at a murder trial, during the investigation of which, he found the "bloody glove". The defense will play this tape as evidence that Officer Karsnia is a racist and planted said glove. This gay McCarthyism could get dangerous. With black Republicans having Oreo cookies thrown at them, are secretly rumored gay republicans going to have closet doors thrown at them. g.scott · September 3, 2007 11:49 PM Actually, I wondered if the "going down the tubes" comment was directed at gay people in general. As in, "even Senators are gay now, we must be going down the tubes." Phelps · September 5, 2007 11:43 AM Post a comment
You may use basic HTML for formatting.
|
|
September 2007
WORLD-WIDE CALENDAR
Search the Site
E-mail
Classics To Go
Archives
September 2007
August 2007 July 2007 June 2007 May 2007 April 2007 March 2007 February 2007 January 2007 December 2006 November 2006 October 2006 September 2006 August 2006 July 2006 June 2006 May 2006 April 2006 March 2006 February 2006 January 2006 December 2005 November 2005 October 2005 September 2005 August 2005 July 2005 June 2005 May 2005 April 2005 March 2005 February 2005 January 2005 December 2004 November 2004 October 2004 September 2004 August 2004 July 2004 June 2004 May 2004 April 2004 March 2004 February 2004 January 2004 December 2003 November 2003 October 2003 September 2003 August 2003 July 2003 June 2003 May 2003 May 2002 AB 1634 See more archives here Old (Blogspot) archives
Recent Entries
What if they gave a Republican sex scandal and nobody came?
Greenpeace Knocks Wind Out Of Ted Kennedy's Sails I'll never get enough of not enough! America is gone? "when is enough enough?" John Edwards In Iowa When truth was a luxury item Carbon Positive Natural law "Out of the Hood" and "Down the Tubes"
Links
Site Credits
|
|
Thank you for a new facet on this story.I also have a new facet to propose.What if the officer is a closeted gay,projecting his festering guilt on whoever is in the wrong place at the wrong time.