|
February 18, 2007
Honesty deferred?
I agree with Glenn Reynolds and J.D. Johannes: "Support the troops. Let them win."But the Vietnam generation is still sharply divided. I can't find a more perfect example than Senator Charles "just-like-in-the-days-of-Vietnam" Schumer who is bound and determined to plunge the country into another glorious defeat. Of course, he'll say the war was "unwinnable," but this is often turns out to be code language for "wrong and immoral," and the people who talk this way want it to be a self-fulfilling prophecy. Thus, they try to undo whatever victories are acheived by U.S. troops on the ground, so they can turn around and say their lives were "wasted" -- all in the name of "supporting the troops." Sorry, but I've already seen it one time too many during the Vietnam era, and it makes me sick that the anti-war generation -- the ones who came to age under student deferments and have been rationalizing their cowardice ever since -- still have so damned much power. This makes them feel it's their God-given moral duty to decide that their country deserves to lose another war. It's not an entire generation, mind you. But this psychology represents a substantial portion of the pre-1953 boomers -- the ones who stayed in college to avoid the draft, rationalized it into pride, and now consider themselves America's moral conscience instead of America's moral cowards (which is what I think they are). Schumer epitomizes them, and I don't want them to return to power in the White House. For starters, I can't stand to hear them whine about what "heroes" they were, when all they did was saved their own skin from the draft. Perhaps I lived in Berkeley too long, but I just find that kind of sanctimony unbearable, and I don't think it will mellow with age. For the life of me, I don't see why they can't admit for once that they just wanted to save their asses from the draft, and the rest is just rationalized claptrap. Hey. I'm not perfect; I say this as a former Marxist who once hated the U.S. military. Sigh. Perhaps I should be more understanding. I was born in 1954 so I didn't have to deal with the draft. posted by Eric on 02.18.07 at 08:24 AM
Comments
For someone that claims to base policy on reason rather than emotion, this certainly seems like an emotionally reactionary post. Judging from this post, which is completely bereft of any substantive policy analysis and driven wholly by emoting, you're actually pretty representative of the GOP as a whole: all ressentiment, no reason. jpe · February 18, 2007 01:03 PM I wouldn't trust a baby boomer as far as I could throw one, and inasmuch as I'm right in the middle of that demographic cohort, I'm probably not in the best physical condition to throw one a great distance. Oh, and my draft number was 25, if anyone cares. CGHill · February 18, 2007 02:36 PM Vietnam? Triple canopy jungle in Iraq? Maybe if the global warming folks get their act together they could arrange that... Be that as it may, my physical conditions would have put me out of the military, so that was not an option for me. Friends of the family had sons in Vietnam, but they were distant on it. But I did see the effects of 'The Good War': WWII. One Uncle hit the slopes in Italy a few too many times, and came back a broken man, though still with the sweetest nature you could ever want to see. His wife had to live with the sudden, deadly attacks at night where he could not help to know who or what he was attacking. The medications helped but proved to have their own long-term side effects and claimed him late in life. Another uncle never did get to the front: his entire boot camp was hit with meningitis. His mind never recovered from that and he was aloof and suspicious of everyone, trusted few and those with very little and was taciturn throughout what was left of his life. A man broken before he even got to combat. My father's eyesight was so poor that he could not be used in combat, but he served as a civilian engineer ensuring that war production of electrical motors was done properly. He tells of an Italian immigrant friend who did not want to fight so badly that he used acid on his eyes to disqualify himself from combat. I have seen the effects of 'The Good War' on some of the men involved in it. Talked with a test pilot from then Bell Aircraft who worked on the Aircobra and was also one of the first Americans to fly a Spitfire. He demonstrated with bottles as telephone poles how manueverable the plane was and that one 'did not fly the Spitfire but wore it'. Living in the environs where Curtiss-Wright production lines once were, I got to hear the stories of their aircraft from pilots, engineers, ground crew and the travails they went through to ensure that their craft were the best possible for their work. I look at the Nation today and I see people wanting to recoil from the horror of war and its cost. I have seen and experienced those who have paid that price and honored the dead from the extended family who did not make it back from 'The Good War' and 'The War to End All Wars'. If you are unwilling to pay the price for a democracy and commitment of the Nation in wartime, then you cannot expect the blessing of liberty to be held well or hard any more for your Nation. The Revolution saw 10% of the Nation dead, 15% fled to other Crown colonies and an economy in pure and utter ruin. Do not talk about the cost of this back alley brawl in Iraq because it is miniscule compared to that fight... started in 1775, ratified in 1776 with the Rights of Man as an Individual to be held no matter what the government IS. Seven long, hard years of defeat save for a few notable victories including the FINAL one. Then five years in which the Nation was one Shays away from chaos and tyranny. Fighting for this Nation has always had the blood of innocents involved, from the Revolution to this very day. You do not run from such fights no matter what the cost in lives or money. Because that decreases and demeans those that have already fought for your precious liberty and you then hand it on diminished to the next generation. Soon it will be gone, and we will be blamed for not standing up to Tyrants and Despots when they confronted us. This is the fight of the ideology that brought forth a Nation able to fight for liberty, freedom and the Rights of Man as an Individual, and to be a Nation. Nations often do not get to choose which wars they get. But no matter what gets you into such a war, it must be fought to victory. Or the security of those precious rights and freedoms is put at peril and they are diminished by those who would take more of them away. America can no longer afford to run for there is no place to hide. It is, indeed, a small world now. And we have some really rotten neighbors and gangsters in the neighborhood seeking to rob and enslave us. They don't appear to listen to reason and would just as rather kill as talk. We can either join with our friends in this and start to put an end to the bad actors, or die separately, quivering inside our homes and asking to be spared... and putting ourselves at the mercy of barbarians. And if you do hide under the bed, then the hand that will reach you will be the blood slick hand of the Enemies of Freedom pulling you out to bring their world to you. This butcher must be put paid to, even though the cost never ends. For the interest is far, far cheaper than when they come for the principle because their price sheet includes every one of us. Ready to be checked off. In our own blood. ajacksonian · February 18, 2007 03:09 PM I will admit that one aspect of the Vietnam era left has always confused me. They say that we lost in Vietnam because it was an immoral war (and make the same argument about Iraq, of course). But, isn't that arguing that might makes right? Also, Eric, I was wondering. When you were at Berkely, were most of the troublemakers slightly older than you, or was it a fairly normal age distribution? Jon Thompson · February 18, 2007 03:21 PM 2 . To repeal the Military Selective Service Act. (Introduced in House)[H.R.424.IH]
CDE · February 18, 2007 03:57 PM "For the life of me, I don't see why they can't admit for once that they just wanted to save their asses from the draft, and the rest is just rationalized claptrap." Frank · February 18, 2007 11:25 PM 'Scuse me. Boomer here. Born 1946. Both parents Army Captains during WWII. Got my draft notice in 1965. Joined the Marines because I'd rather make some other dumb SOB die for his country than die myself. Viet Nam was worth the fight, but the fight was directed by fools at the civilian levels. In spite of that it was won, then lost after the fact by the Chuck Schumers (and John Kerry) of the day. Freedom isn't free, and isn't cash and carry. It's paid for on the installment plan, and any generation that thinks it's getting a free ride only makes the next generation pay their installment plus its own, with interest. Try to ride free long enough, and foreclosure comes. Schumer & Co. think they can ride free forever. The price they're willing to pay is less liberty, for everyone but them of course. And of course it's the children and grandchildren of the Boomer generation (my generation) who will pay the actual price, in blood. Pay a small price now, or a huge price later. Those are the choices. RightWingNutter · February 19, 2007 03:57 AM Post a comment
You may use basic HTML for formatting.
|
|
February 2007
WORLD-WIDE CALENDAR
Search the Site
E-mail
Classics To Go
Archives
February 2007
January 2007 December 2006 November 2006 October 2006 September 2006 August 2006 July 2006 June 2006 May 2006 April 2006 March 2006 February 2006 January 2006 December 2005 November 2005 October 2005 September 2005 August 2005 July 2005 June 2005 May 2005 April 2005 March 2005 February 2005 January 2005 December 2004 November 2004 October 2004 September 2004 August 2004 July 2004 June 2004 May 2004 April 2004 March 2004 February 2004 January 2004 December 2003 November 2003 October 2003 September 2003 August 2003 July 2003 June 2003 May 2003 May 2002 See more archives here Old (Blogspot) archives
Recent Entries
The Culture War (and why "we" fight)
Congressman Manzullo Speaks Terrorists In Georgia USA? Scrotal Marxism for kids? Dishonest (and disabling) deferment Cultural Marxism Clinton On Iraq The Victory Caucus Honesty deferred? Palestinians Are At It Again
Links
Site Credits
|
|
During my college years (1955 to 1959) I had four very close male friends. The draft was on. Here is how we avoided the it. One of my friends joined the Air Force. One became a doctor, was later drafted and served in Viet Nam as an Army doctor. I joined ROTC and avoided the draft by becoming an Army lieutenant of Infantry. One was drafted, served in the Army and was assigned to post-war Korea, where we still have a significant force. So all of us served pre-Viet Nam except the doc. Half of us were drafted. I am proud of all of us, but the choices I must admit were in some ways forced. Je regrette rien.