Culture War is Religious War, claims Buchanan

Noting the hopeless religious divide between Barack Obama and James Dobson, Pat Buchanan (on Dobson's side, naturally) argues that peaceful coexistence is impossible:

Can Americans ever come together if we are divided in our deepest beliefs about morality and truth, where one side believes gay marriage is moral progress, the other holds it a moral outrage; where one side views abortion to be a mighty advance for women's freedom, the other sees it as legalization of mass slaughter of unborn babies?

There can be no peaceful coexistence in a cultural war because it is at root a religious war. Far into the future, Americans seem fated to face each other again and again "at some disputed barricade."

Well, I've touched on this divide before, and while the disagreements are indeed hopeless, I'm not sure why that necessarily renders peaceful coexistence impossible.

Is Buchanan using these terms rhetorically, or is he expecting a shooting war to start?

Judging from the things Buchanan has been saying (whether "inartfully" or not) lately, he might simply mean that peaceful coexistence with Pat Buchanan is becoming impossible.

MORE: I know it's old news, but since I touched on the subject earlier today, I guess it's fair to point out that Pat Buchanan has been fond of rhetorical "sodomite" bashing for years. (It hardly compares to the stuff he's saying about the Jews, though.)

posted by Eric on 07.01.08 at 04:31 PM


There is nothing moral about the government being involved in marriage at all. If a religion wishes to allow two men or two women to marry then they should be allowed, and the federal government can go pound salt.

John   ·  July 1, 2008 6:30 PM

Given that Buchanan apparently believes that the eight-year disagreement between Iran and Iraq in the '80's that left about a million people dead does NOT rise to the level of "War"... (here) I shudder to think what he expects to happen here if he is willing to deploy the "w" word.

Clint   ·  July 1, 2008 10:39 PM


Sorry. Got my Buchanans confused. Pat =/= James. Very different wings of the GOP.

Clint   ·  July 1, 2008 10:41 PM

Pat Buchanan, formerly one of my personal heroes, has either lately gone off the deep end, or gone off his crazy pills. Either way, I'm going to stop listening to him until such time as he comes to his senses.

Best Regards,
A. Truman North

ATNorth   ·  July 1, 2008 11:52 PM

Actually, Eric, I was surprised to see his name here. I know that the Left loves to trot him out as a "Republican", in part because of his predictably embarrasing comments.

You gotta admit, the guy has credentials.

But, in the main, I ignore him. And the sooner the Right ignores or distances itself from him, the better. IMHO.


OregonGuy   ·  July 2, 2008 1:30 AM

OregonGuy: he HAD Republican credentials, but blew 'em all by 2000 when he ran against the Republicans on the national-socialist ticket. Conservative organisations like NR had excommunicated him years before that.

I keep trying to explain this to people. Buchanan is a reactionary nationalist, not a conservative, and has no influence in the Bush-McCain party leadership.

David Ross   ·  July 2, 2008 5:33 PM

Here's a hint: all these folks are already peacefully coexisting.

None of these folks are engaging in violence. None are urging the state to use its power to shut up the other.

All these folks are doing is disagreeing with the other and trying to convince the rest of us to agree with them and not to use the power of the state to enhance the position of the other.

That sounds pretty peaceful to me.

Really, it's silly to miss all this amidst the emotion and fervor of these folks making their points. If we were living in Iran, one of these folks would be having their head chopped off.

See what not peacefully coexisting really looks like?

Paul A'Barge   ·  July 2, 2008 10:44 PM

Paul, an excellent reality check.

My guess on Buchanan is that he is remarkably good at understanding how individuals tick, and has used this to provide insights into them that others miss. His ability for sustained abstract thought, however has never impressed me.

Assistant Village Idiot   ·  July 3, 2008 4:26 PM

Post a comment

April 2011
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
          1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30


Search the Site


Classics To Go

Classical Values PDA Link


Recent Entries


Site Credits