graves and graven images

When Glenn Reynolds linked my PINO CHE T shirt design post, he commented that it had the potential to "create all sorts of amusing commotion." I assumed Glenn meant political commotion, but the commotion which has happened so far is copyright commotion.

While copyright commotion can be amusing, it can also be annoying. Anyway, when I uploaded the design to a leading T-shirt designer, everything seemed to work, and I was actually given a URL where the T-shirt could be sold. No big deal there. I thought all was well, and I put the link in my post so people could order it.

Pino_Che_T_Front.jpg

But last night, I got the following email from the T-shirt company:

We recently learned that your CafePress.com account contains material which may not be in compliance with our policies. Specifically, designing, manufacturing, marketing and/or selling products that may infringe the rights of a third party, including, copyrights (e.g., an image of a television cartoon character), trademarks (e.g., the logo of a company), "rights in gross" (e.g., the exclusive right of the U.S. Olympic Committee to use the "Olympic Rings"), and rights of privacy and publicity (e.g., a photo of a celebrity) are prohibited.

Accordingly, we have set the content that we believe to be questionable to "pending status" which disables said content from being displayed in your shop or purchased by the public.

I emailed back asking for an explanation, as both Guevara and Pinochet are dead, and the image I designed is a composite of two widely circulated political designs which were derived from photographs taken long ago. (Along with a satirical caption which plays on both names.) It is quite obvious that the juxtaposition is intended as parody. Parody is exempt from copyright enforcement.

So I wonder what is going on.

I'd hate to think that Che or his photographer are trying to censor me from beyond the grave!

MORE: The copyright parody plot thickens. Commenter Meleva suggested I go into cafepress and search for famous images, which I did.

Considering they sell t-shirts featuring the original Korda photograph like this one (from which the rest are derivative), obviously that's not the copyright issue that's causing the commotion.

taserchesm.jpg

Furthermore, they also feature t-shirts featuring the same Pinochet image on which I based the design!

pinochetvoodoo_lg.jpg

So I'm more confused than ever. If neither image alone has copyright problems, then what's behind the commotion?

MORE: As I suspected, the Korda image is the problem. I just received this reply to my request for an explanation:

Thank you for contacting CafePress.com!

Unfortunately we have pended your Korda Che Guevara based image. Please understand that we feel Che is a political figure and that it is appropriate to use original, public domain or licensed images of Che on the CafePress.com Web site, however, the Korda Che Guevara image is a photograph that is protected by copyright laws and use of the actual image, or any derivatives can be viewed as copyright infringement.
We have been in contact with the attorney for the Korda estate, and below please find his contact information. We are more than happy to allow you to use the image if you obtain permission.
Maitre Randy Yolaz
Cabinet D'Avocats - Law Offices
17, Bis Avenue Foch
75116 Paris France
Tel: +33 1.40.67.99.10
Fax: +33 1.45.00.69.66
Sorry for the inconvenience. Once again, we do view Che as a political figure and allow pro or anti Che merchandise, however, your particular image is too similar to the original Korda photograph. Please note that merely altering the image is not sufficient, you need to create your own original work and it cannot resemble the unique features of the Korda photograph.

Unlike other major t-shirt producers like ThoseShirts.com, apparently, Cafe Press does not understand that parody is not infringement.

The Wiki entry for the Korda photo provides some background on the copyright issue. As Cuba was a non-signatory to the Berne convention, the image was widely reproduced for 40 years without any copyright protection. (Castro consider stated that he considered copyright law "imperialist bullshit," but he seemed to change his tune in 1997.) A couple of years later, Korda was upset by a Smirnoff vodka ad and sued in Britain, where he won a $50,000 judgment. Here's a brief summary:

A recent international case dealt with this: a Cuban photographer (Alberto Korda) took many pictures of Ché Guevara (never taking public credit for them), and for years allowed anyone who wanted to use them to do so (because he felt that it immortalized Ché, as well as the Cuban revolution). A few years ago, Smirnoff vodka used some of these images in an ad campaign; the photographer did not like this, and complained about copyright infringement. Seagram's (the company that makes Smirnoff) countered that the photographer had allowed the copyrights to fall into public domain because he had made no attempt to stop the many people who had used the images before without asking permission. By strictest interpretation, they were right (the pictures were made pre-Berne, they were never registered, no notice of copyright had ever been given, and world-wide use had been allowed with no attempt to stop or even notify the infringers), but the government of Cuba put some pressure on the English government to protect the copyrights. In a purely political move, Seagram's backed down, but all this says is that if you don't have the backing of a large governmental agency, you can possibly lose your copyrights to public domain.
Che's family says they're planning to fight what they call "infringement." Hah!

I'd be willing to bet that they'll never dare sue ThoseShirts.com, because they'd certainly lose in any United States court. (Those cowardly British courts. Again!)

The more I thought about Cafe Press's attitude, the more annoyed I became.

Next I discovered that I am not alone. Cafe Press also censored The People's Cube for this "infringement":

Che_dead._verboten.gif

Not only is it pure parody, it doesn't even resemble the Korda photo. Moreover, The People's Cube documents countless instances of parodies of corporate logos none of which Cafe Press is interested in protecting.

What a priceless double standard.

Parody capitalismo sí!

Parody communismo no!

And in what I think is a priceless act of retaliation, The People's Cube now has their own Cafe Press Parody Site!

UPDATE: The official PINO CHE T is now for sale here!

UPDATE (10/19/07): The Printfection link will no longer work, so (only after great reluctance) I redesigned the T-shirt yet again, minus the Korda design which upset the companies. It is now for sale at Cafe Press.

PINO CHENoKorda_T.jpg

PLEASE NOTE: The above is not the Korda image, nor is it derived from it.

However, it remains my opinion that the Korda image is in the public domain, and that in any event it may be freely parodied.

posted by Eric on 10.16.07 at 10:27 AM





TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://classicalvalues.com/cgi-bin/pings.cgi/5674






Comments

eric,

if you go into cafepress and search the word "communist", you will find plenty of famous images.

meleva

William and Meleva   ·  October 16, 2007 12:40 PM

my personal favorite:

William and Meleva   ·  October 16, 2007 12:43 PM

They haven't given me any trouble about my shirt:

http://www.cafepress.com/chaikaroma.37814292

But to be fair, mine's pretty far away from the original.

chaika   ·  October 16, 2007 03:29 PM

They are very selective as to what they will not accept.

Mark   ·  October 22, 2007 09:05 PM

It looks like the new and improved Cafe Press one is gone now too.

chaika   ·  October 25, 2007 10:57 AM

Yeah, you're right. The fact that they won't even tolerate a non-Korda image belies their claim that they're only interested in copyright enforcement.

They have not answered my last email.

Eric Scheie   ·  October 25, 2007 11:06 AM

Post a comment

You may use basic HTML for formatting.





Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)



November 2007
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
        1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30  

ANCIENT (AND MODERN)
WORLD-WIDE CALENDAR


Search the Site


E-mail




Classics To Go

Classical Values PDA Link



Archives




Recent Entries



Links



Site Credits