Meet the beetles! (A taxing argument for traditional values?)
An email from a friend directed me to some vital science news. It appears that two scientists have named slime mold beetles for Bush, Cheney and Rumsfeld!
The following comes from the text forwarded to me without a link:
Slime-Mold Beetles Named for Politicians
Grumps and cynics often compare politicians to worms, bugs and other creepy-crawly creatures. Now, some bugs have been named after three of the world's most powerful politicians. Two American entomologists have named three newly discovered species of slime-mold beetles after President Bush, Vice President Dick Cheney and Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld. Lest anyone think that Agathidium bushi, Agathidium cheneyi and Agathidium rumsfeldi were named out of spite for Messrs. Bush, Cheney and Rumsfeld, their nomenclators insist it's a sign of respect. "We admire these leaders as fellow citizens who have the courage of their convictions and are willing to do the very difficult and unpopular work of living up to principles of freedom and democracy rather than accepting the expedient or popular," said former Cornell entomologist Quentin Wheeler, now the head of entomology at the Natural History Museum in London. Think of that next time you see the Agathidium bushi feasting on mold in its stomping grounds in southern Ohio, North Carolina and Virginia (all red states, in the last election).
Intrigued by this, my immediate reaction was to put up a blog post, but I like to verify facts before I run around repeating possible Internet rumors and urban legends. Sure enough, I found a scientific abstract listing the above species!
Two US scientists have paid tribute to their favourite politicians by naming three species of beetle after them.
President George Bush, Vice-President Dick Cheney and Defence Secretary Donald Rumsfeld were all honoured.
One of the entomologists said he admired all three men for "having the courage of their convictions" and standing up for freedom and democracy.
The three beetles who now bear their names are among 65 newly discovered species which feed on mould.
The scientists, Quentin Wheeler and Kelly Miller, discovered the insects after collecting thousands of specimens for study and classification, according to a press release from Cornell University where Mr Wheeler used to work.
'Prominent teeth'
They named them Agathidium bushi, Agathidium cheneyi and Agathidium rumsfeldi.
Others were named after the scientists' wives, the Star Wars villain Darth Vader and the Greek words for "ugly" and "having prominent teeth".
But Mr Wheeler, who is now head of entomology at London's Natural History Museum, said the decision to name three beetles after politicians had nothing to do with physical features.
"One has to be creative with names," he told the BBC news website.
"We are two of the only politically conservative scientists around, and we decided to stick our necks out." (Emphasis added.)
The contention that these men were "conservative scientists" intrigued me even more, as I'm used to seeing creative uses of political terminology, and I've been known to do so myself.
According to science-oriented blogger John Daly, Quentin Wheeler has (along with the controversial E.O. Wilson) in fact co-authored an important argument for "traditional taxonomy":
... traditional taxonomy has been downsized in favor of molecular techniques, and as a result we are running out of knowledge with which to properly interpret the DNA data. They call for a new synthesis of traditional, molecular and ICT based approaches.
Mr. Daly thinks that President Bush should be paying more attention to traditional taxonomy, which he argues is more important than the space program.
Certainly, insect naming is one way to direct the Bush administration's attention to long-neglected traditional taxonomic values.
Sure sounds conservative to me!
(But then, I've been fooled before....)
As to Dr. Wheeler's beetles, I have to admit, they all look the same. Didn't Spiro Agnew say something like, "When you've seen one, you've seen 'em all?"
posted by Eric on 04.14.05 at 01:45 PM
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://classicalvalues.com/cgi-bin/pings.cgi/2211
Actually, I always consider naming bugs to be a sign of respect. This page lists all of the famous people names that scientists have used; new species don't come along often enough for scientists to use up naming rights on petty hates.
Since the Linnean system of taxonomy is under review and probably will be scrapped in favor of something more straighforward, this bit of tomfoolery is pretty meaningless and the way to grab a headline or two. Go get 'em boys!
Yep...I am no big head in the field of science....just a mere strapling who checks it out every now and again, but I do seem to remember that amongst scientists, to name ANY creature/plant after a friend was considered the highest form of honor. If you have read any of the O'Brian Aubrey/Maturin series, you know that Maturin was always on the lookout for unique beetles for a friend and 'spy supervisor' (so to speak) who specialized and loved studying beetles.
You all need to stop and realize that there are thousands and thousands of species out there. It is not that easy coming up with names. Did YOU go to college for years and years to earn the right to name newly discovered beetles? I don't think so. They have every right to have fun while doing so. I can assure you, this was NOT a way to "grab the headlines". I'm sure that you would name a new species that you discovered after someone that you admire. Why can't they? Before you know all the details, don't go criticizing their actions. If I were you, I would also take a closer look at those beetles. They look nothing alike.
Actually, I always consider naming bugs to be a sign of respect. This page lists all of the famous people names that scientists have used; new species don't come along often enough for scientists to use up naming rights on petty hates.