|
|
|
|
May 09, 2006
The conspiracy theorists' conspiracy theorist's conspiracy theorist?
I hate this. But I guess I was asking for it when in a comment I facetiously referred to "line by line fisking of long passages by the likes of Paul Krugman," because a friend has sent me his latest piece, titled "Who's Crazy Now?" I can't take on the whole Krugman piece, because my blogger burnout is bad enough already. And I don't want to commit copyright violations. So, I'll just stick with the two final paragraphs -- lifted not greedily from the Times, but gratefully from my friend's email: But now those harsh critics have been vindicated. And it turns out that many of the administration supporters can't handle the truth. They won't admit that they built a personality cult around a man who has proved almost pathetically unequal to the job. Nor will they admit that opponents of the Iraq war, whom they called traitors for warning that invading Iraq was a mistake, have been proved right. So they have taken refuge in the belief that a vast conspiracy of America-haters in the media is hiding the good news from the public.It has a nice sort of flow, doesn't it? A sing-songy quality which I'd really like if only I could agreed with what Krugman says. Perhaps most Krugman readers do, but I don't. I guess I should explain why. ...[N]ow those harsh [Bush] critics have been vindicated.The harsh ones have? Who? Cindy Sheehan? Michael Moore? Ward Churchill? Ed Asner? Why isn't Krugman more specific? Who has been vindicated, and how? Why so open-ended? Without examples, I don't know where to start. Does Krugman like it like that? And it turns out that many of the administration supporters can't handle the truth.Which truth? The truth of 9/11? The truth that WMDs weren't found? They won't admit that they built a personality cult around a man who has proved almost pathetically unequal to the job.(Well, at least he was generous enough to say "almost.") But personality cult? I held my nose and voted for the man, and I have always had my disagreements. That Bush has been the butt of so many jokes tended to make me feel sorry for him, but I don't think Bush deprecation is what Krugman meant. The personality cult is a well-recognized phenomenon of totalitarian societies, in which the great leader becomes a substitute for God: Personality cults usually characterize totalitarian, authoritarian, or one-party states, especially those with a strong revolutionary consciousness. The reputation of a single leader, often characterized as the "liberator" or "savior" of the people, elevates that leader to a near-divine level.A typical example: "Stalin is our Leader and Teacher, the Greatest Genius of All Times and All Nations, the Sun of Our Planet."While it is possible that someone may have written something like that about Bush somewhere, it would more likely be satire, and accompanied by one of the usual cartoons showing Bush as a chimpanzee, or with a Hitler moustache. To be fair to Krugman, he has complained about the "personality cult" before, and says it involves politically staged pictures of Bush -- something Krugman called "deeply un-American." (At least Krugman dislikes "un-Americanism.") Nor will they admit that opponents of the Iraq war, whom they called traitors for warning that invading Iraq was a mistake, have been proved right.Who are "they"? Who was called a traitor? Who issued the warnings? Certainly not the vast majority of Democrats in Congress. Can't Krugman supply a few examples? And what constitutes the proof that the invasion was a mistake? His assertion? As to the characterization of people as "traitors," while it's not a habit of mine, Krugman certainly feels free to call people "deeply un-American" so I'm wondering about the sincerity of his outrage. So they have taken refuge in the belief that a vast conspiracy of America-haters in the media is hiding the good news from the public.That depends on the definition of "good news," doesn't it? How would something like the battle of Fallujah be reported? 92 Americans killed, and 1000 "insurgents" killed. What would Krugman have seen as the "good news" and what would he have seen as the "bad news"? Is any war news good news? This failure to define terms makes me suspect that Krugman is a bit of a sneak -- one of those guys who will always be right (and whose opponents are always wrong). Unlike the crazy conspiracy theories of the left — which do exist, but are supported only by a tiny fringe — the crazy conspiracy theories of the right are supported by important people: powerful politicians, television personalities with large audiences.Oh come on! There are crazy conspiracy theories of the left -- Bush rigging the Twin Towers with explosives being a good example -- just as there are crazy conspiracy theories of the right. And there are always important people (like Ed Asner) to support them. But Krugman is not talking about allegations that Senator Dodd was Stalin's grandson; he means skepticism about Global warming, and allegations that "the liberal media are suppressing the good news from Iraq." Expressing Global Warming skepticism -- even indignantly as Senator Inhofe did -- does not meet the "wikipedia definition" cited by Krugman A conspiracy theory attempts to explain the cause of an event as a secret, and often deceptive, plot by a covert alliance rather than as an overt activity or as natural occurrence.There's nothing covert about a large number of scientists sharing the same view. Saying that they are wrong -- even that they are perpetrating a hoax -- is not conspiracy theorizing without an allegation of a secret motive. Nor is it enough to say that they are "environmentalists." Now, had Inhofe said that they were all secretly in the employ of a tiny clique of OPEC insiders who wanted to make a fortune by undermining their own industry and selling short, that would be a conspiracy theory. But disagreement -- no matter how unreasonable it might appear -- does not a conspiracy theory make. Also dismissed as a conspiracy theory is the idea that "the liberal media are suppressing the good news from Iraq." Without getting into the merits, the charge involves a very commonplace allegation of media bias. Functionally, it's no different than my complaints that the Philadelphia Inquirer is biased against guns, or that WorldNetDaily is biased against gays. Am I alleging secret conspiracies? Hardly. But if we assume Krugman is right, then he's uncovered a new conspiracy to see conspiracy theories, and by the standard he applies to others, then he too must be a conspiracy theorist. But I won't make such an allegation, for that would make me part of a conspiracy to spot a conspiracy theorist theorist, and I'm uncomfortable with such a role. I'd hate to be wrong, and I wouldn't want to be right! And we can safely predict that these people will never concede that they were wrong.Yes, we can. Especially if we don't define them. That's because there are always plenty of people who can be depended on never, ever, to admit "they" are wrong. I'm not a regular Krugman reader, but if my memory serves me well I don't think he makes it a habit to admit errors himself. (Not even when the Times' public editor calls him on it!) When the Iraq venture comes to a bad end, they won't blame those who led us into the quagmire; they'll claim that it was all the fault of the liberal media, which stabbed our troops in the back.By using the word "when," Krugman would seem to allow as a theoretical possibility that the Iraq venture hasn't yet come to a bad end. What would be a good end, though? If the people behind the war are "deeply un-American," I can only wonder. (As to Krugman's threshold question -- "Who's crazy now?" -- I think I am. Either that or this whole thing has given me a headache. But either way, it's nothing new.) UPDATE: Via Glenn Reynolds, here's Captain Ed: . . .the Americans are winning the media war in Iraq. That's something that the American media has yet to report in any substantive way.Americans? Winning? That's obviously another conspiracy theory. posted by Eric on 05.09.06 at 10:16 AM
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://classicalvalues.com/cgi-bin/pings.cgi/3585 Listed below are links to weblogs that reference The conspiracy theorists' conspiracy theorist's conspiracy theorist?:
» Athena’s Wisdom on Presidential Criticism from Gay Patriot
Finally getting caught up on my reading after the craziness of these past few weeks and discovered this gem in Peggy’s column last week: To criticize the White House–if the criticism is serious, well-grounded and well-meant–is helpful... [Read More] Tracked on May 10, 2006 05:52 AM
Comments
Why is it that so many Bush-haters seems to think there is some personality cult around the president. Nearly every conservative blog I have read has criticized the president at one time or another. And I can't think of a single serious conservative who esteems the current president more than his last two-term Republican predecessor. Dan (AKA GayPatriotWest) · May 10, 2006 05:38 AM The harsh ones have? Who? Cindy Sheehan? Michael Moore? Ward Churchill? Ed Asner? Why isn't Krugman more specific? Who has been vindicated, and how? Um...how about all those generals who were forced out after saying we'd need more troops to restore order in Iraq than Rummy wanted to send? How about all those Americans who weren't too keen on invading Iraq in the first place? The list you demand would number in the tens of millions. Pretending that only the loony-left criticize Bush, only proves Krugman right: you can't handle the truth. Raging Bee · May 10, 2006 03:19 PM Bee you completely miss the point. Without EXAMPLES of harsh criticism it is impossible to refute Krugman. Er, wait, Eric said it better: Harkonnendog · May 10, 2006 04:20 PM |
|
December 2006
WORLD-WIDE CALENDAR
Search the Site
E-mail
Classics To Go
Archives
December 2006
November 2006 October 2006 September 2006 August 2006 July 2006 June 2006 May 2006 April 2006 March 2006 February 2006 January 2006 December 2005 November 2005 October 2005 September 2005 August 2005 July 2005 June 2005 May 2005 April 2005 March 2005 February 2005 January 2005 December 2004 November 2004 October 2004 September 2004 August 2004 July 2004 June 2004 May 2004 April 2004 March 2004 February 2004 January 2004 December 2003 November 2003 October 2003 September 2003 August 2003 July 2003 June 2003 May 2003 May 2002 See more archives here Old (Blogspot) archives
Recent Entries
Holiday Blogging
The right to be irrational? I'm cool with the passion fashion Climate change meltdown at the polls? If you're wrong, then so is God? Have a nice day, asshole! Scarlet "R"? Consuming power while empowering consumption Shrinking is growth! My dirty thoughts
Links
Alphecca (My Blogdaddy) ![]() ![]() Puff the Protector Andrew Sullivan Gays in Military Site Middle East Media Research Institute Gay Libertarian Site The Bitch Girls Join the NRA! SECOND AMENDMENT VIDEO! Shooters' Carnival
Tammy Bruce Gun Owners of America
David Hackworth
Hell In A Handbasket Matt Welch The Volokh Conspiracy Virginia Postrel PseudoPsalms The Light of Reason The Anger of Compassion Anger Management Dustbury.com Rachel Lucas Shadow Government reflections in d minor JustOneMinute Boone Country Catallarchy Agenda Bender Mike Silverman Steven Malcolm Anderson Walter in Denver Impearls Donald Sensing Howard Owens Loco Parentis Colby Cosh VodkaPundit Radley Balko Dean's World The Queen of All Evil baldilocks Joe Gandelman Dave Tepper Begging to Differ Kesher Talk Jeff Jarvis Doc Searls Little Green Footballs Captain Ed Oh, That Liberal Media! ICANNfocus.org God of the Machine Sandefur's Freespace Wizbang Robert Prather LawPundit The Anti-Idiotarian Rottweiler
Amygdala bilious young fogey MadLab On the Fritz why dave bergman is neat Skiplog Clowning Glory Dispatches from the Culture Wars Where in Washington, D.C. is Sun Myung Moon? Anti-Socialist Tendencies Of Interest WICKED THOUGHTS Setting The World To Rights doubleplusgood infotainment It Can't Rain All The Time Scrutineer Nick Danger, International Man of Mystery seldom sober TRITICALE Random Jottings Graham Lester point2point Shark Blog Gene Healy Discount Blogger Six Foot Pole Dodgeblogium Across the Atlantic The Imperialist Dog Lex Talionis Mind Of Mog Say Uncle CAMPVS MAWRTIVS res gestae dionysii Annika's Journal & Poetry A :{FRUSTRATED}: ARTIST Yet another weird SF fan Lincoln Cat The Meatriarchy Who is Ronald? Short Daddy Punch Drunk Mookie Riffic On The Third Hand MatthewEdgar.net ZenPundit Jennifer's History and Stuff argghhh!!! Modulator D.C. Thornton Centerfield Asymmetrical Information Airline Pilots Security Assn Relapsed Catholic PAPADOC Abraca-Pocus The Pryhills Winds of Change Daily Pundit The Speculist Regnum Crucis The Elfin Ethicist Classics in Contemporary Culture elephant-rabbits A Perfectly Cromulent Blog allied Parableman Southern Musings CALIFORNIA YANKEE Allen's Arena Ex-Gay Watch Jonno Michael Moore doesn't love me! Eschaton Clayton Cramer Letters From a Strip of Dirt Oliver Willis Hesiod Theogeny Dr Zen JunkYardBlog Orcinus Ideofact Letter from Gotham Oraculations INCITE Positive Liberty ALLAH IS IN THE HOUSE Tiny Little Lies My So-Called Penis Keith Devens Jason Holliston W(h)ine Country Straight White Guy Ken MacLeod Lawrence Lessig PaleoJudaica.com EdCone.com Common Sense and Wonder Who knew? Daily Howler James Landrith Chief Wiggles L.T. Smash damnum absque injuria Daniel W. Drezner OxBlog Reason of Voice Steven Den Beste Wonkette! Cranial Cavity Gibberish in Neutral DramaQueen vivalabloog Classics in Contemporary Culture The LLama Butchers HobbsOnLine ACIDMAN Sector 7-G Zogby Blog mtpolitics.net Horologium Civic Dialogues Practical Penumbra Right Wing News Stranger in a Strange Land Ambient Irony Tiger: Raggin' & Rantin' Read My Lips Jay Solo The Alliance The Smallest Minority Wrong Side of Happiness Wince and Nod One Little Victory Fishbucket suburban blight Sketches of Strain Boi from Troy Being American in T.O. Outside the Beltway One Fine Jay Bill and Kent's Place on the Web Burton Terrace This Book Stinks The Happy Carpenter Political Correctness Watch GREENIE WATCH Resource.full This Liberal" Brainville BLAMBLOG Ordinary Galoot QandO Josh Cohen Extra Ordinary Ideas brykMantra Croooow Blog Old Right commiewatch Proculian Meditations UggaBugga Dustin the No-Longer-Blogless Les Jones Blog Temporal Globe Postcards from Nowhere Tarazet Unfogged Synthstuff Riba Rambles Mitch Berg The National Debate scha-den-freu-de Ocean Guy Topic Exchange CELESTIAL OFFERINGS Texas Native Somewhere over the Rainbough Why read this? End NPR Bias Ace of Spades HQ Web Dawn GANGSTORIES Sheila Astray's Redheaded Ramblings Alan Sullivan (Seablogger) hobbyblog FuturePundit.com Tim Blair A Voyage To Arcturus HipperCritical BarlowFriendz Jihad Watch Kin's Kouch Bad Money The Campblog News Junkie Canada De Doc's Doings Bigwig Eject!Eject!Eject! Tom's Nap Room A Coon Cat's World The sexual adventures of Woodie and Peaches Crystalline Ceramics Web Resource Heh. Indeed. NakedVillainy.com Andrew David Chamberlain The Karmic Inquisition Adam Smith Institute Weblog Andrea Harris Hi. I'm Black Banana Oil Jim Miller on Politics Who Tends the Fires Ranck and File MOLOTOV COCKTAIL FRANK NOLI IRRITARE LEONES Miss O'Hara deadmaus Coffee With Rhoads robot guy Travelling Shoes Admiral Quixote's Roundtable danm.us The Argus Dissecting Leftism Dissecting Leftism -- OLD Site Aaron's cc Commentariat The Argus - Registan INDC Journal Pundit Ex Machina DeMythology Peppermint Tea Gilly's World Beyond the Black Hole La Shawn Barber" Perverse Access Memory Invisible Adjunct Photon Courier Intel Dump Junkscience.com The SmarterCop Laban Tall Banagor Peeve Farm Rand Simberg camedwards.com Kim du Toit Mrs. du Toit Dancing with Dogs Two--Four Heretical Ideas Astonished Head Outlandish Josh Central Oregon for Dean The White Peril 白禍 (Sean Kinsell) www.blktlr.com Subterranean Bungalo DFMoore Dave Halliday Well Versed Qoheleth 60: Joel Moody's Repository quo vado jonrowe.blogspot.com yellopad Sticks of Fire Dissecting Leftism ByteMagick Blogs of War PRESTOPUNDIT Of Interest The Meatriarchy Bernhardt Varenius The Forager Miller?s Time Blogs of War painting to stay (?) sane Blue Goldfish | Surface Clowning Glory House of Payne International Last Chance Caf馬t;/a> Psychology of Leftism a_sdf CONSERVATISM/RIGHTISM Taylor & Company The Vicious Circle Leftists as Elitists Eye of the Storm A scratch area Wicked Thoughts Filtrat The Bayou City Perspective The Belfry Blogger Setting The World To Rights Ljonn.com Oddly Normal Varifrank Jamie Jamison on Technology GayPatriot A New York Escorts Confessions jamescalvin.com The Eleven Day Empire Dr. Rusty Shackleford Eric's Grumles Before The Grave Belmont Club Gumbo Pie BeldarBlog MooreThoughts Blind Adherence Last One Speaks Logic Monkey Bird's Eye View DIRTY WATER Forgadring precision-guided cowboy Punditmania Minor Thoughts Just Askin' HispaLibertas Let's Try Freedom Megan McArdle Ann Althouse Beautiful Atrocities Sean Hackbarth Power and Control Professor Bainbridge Power Line Dialogic Darleen's Place I'm N.O. Pundit! Done With Mirrors AMERICAN FUTURE CodeBlueBlog Gay Orbit Urthshu Zacht Ei Interested-Participant blake taylor The Anchoress Freespeech.com Spiked Decision '08 (Mark Coffey) White Lightning Axiom: Redux The Big Picture Rachel Lucas BEI John Cole Haight Speech evolution: on the loose Moderates of all Nations, Unite! Jeff Gannon THE GLEESON BLOGLOMERATE Pajama Pundits Centerpiece The Radical Centrist Lab-Tested FreedomSight AmbivaBlog evolution Marx & Friends in their own words Elective Application Religion Research Islam Blog YOUNGPUNDIT.COM {finding peace in the chaos} IQ & PC -- By Chris Brand Classics in Contemporary Culture Morse's Code A&W Bench Marx Julie Neidlinger Shades of Gray The Daily Lion: NeoLibertarianism on a Stick Miller's Time Centerpiece This Liberal Coming Anarchy Lay Lines that'sRich the blog eclectic booklore Yankee Madmen Jesusland Expatriate Amazing Motor Girls Spiced Sass Decline and Fall of Western Civilization Modern Crusader MaroonBlog Skriblerier, etc. I am partially fused with infinity Eros Colored Glasses Bill Peschel: The man comes around The Twins Tell the Truth wickens.ca The War of Ideas ConsterNations EaglesUp Blog Vitriolics Anonymous DIRTY WATER Mean Mr. Mustard 2.0 EDUCATION WATCH THE RIGHT SCALE AIS Knight Hammer SOCIALIZED MEDICINE The Argus DON'T BE DUMB! Blue Goldfish | Surface GUN WATCH De Docs Institute for Memetic Engineering And Polymaths... Wordpress Test Weblog Kapowie Zone Political Theory: Weblogs You know, they say... all blogged down Harkonnendog Big Dirigible GeoPoliticalreview.com Coyote Blog Blog Retrofuturistic VietPundit JasonColeman.com Logical Meme Bloggledygook Discursive Recursions Bird's Eye View Right Wing Nut House ELEMENOHPEE Locusts and Honey Moonbattery The Everlasting Phelps Mythusmage Opines The Cassandra Page Of Arms & the Law The Daily Bork Strange Stuff Another Gay Republican Libertarian Man of Mystery Liberty Just In Case TalkLeft Joe's Dartblog Iowa Hawk The Common Room Darth Vader John C. A. Bambenek Gay Bipolar Republican Boxing Alcibiades Baby TrollBlog Strange Fictions Urban Hermit The Eye of Polyphemus Toe In The Water Bryan's Basement Fishkite Right on the Left Coast Beltway Buzz pike speak Scared Monkeys The Mudville Gazette Matt Sheffield Undercaffeinated Trey Jackson NashvilleFiles.com Moonbat Central Dust my Broom The Cliffs of Insanity Riding Sun The Modo Blog Philly Future philly Off In The Tall Weeds Doug Petch.Com Gays for Life the True Nature of Reality Spinning Clio Mike Huckabee President 2008 A.E.Brain that rogueclassicist guy A M㯠Invisí¶¥l Constantly Risking Absurdity Laurence Simon Notes & Musings A World of Speculation Weird Events Pit Bull Wars New World Man Mark in Mexico The Palmetto Pundit All Things Jen(nifer) Generic Confusion Justus for All iHillary Michael Totten Don Surber Maggie's Farm Unpaid Punditry Corps The Counter Hippie Kicking On Doors FunnyBusiness Restless Mania Mark Tapscott nobody sasses a girl in glasses Letters from the Bostonian Exile The Education Wonks Diana Hseih just muttering Right-Wing of the Gods Michelle Malkin Inside Larry's Head Ballpoint Wren A Blog For All The Liberal Wrong American Outlook Splog Reporter From the Grand Stand Tinabell Affordable Housing Institute mudphud Living In The Past Searchlight Crusade Gus Van Horn Ian Schwartz One Billion Red Chinese and a Dog Named Liberty Suburban Bourgeois The Metropolis Times DR. HELEN Philadelphia AIDS Thrift Sir Humphrey's Birth Story The Simplest Thing Blue Star Chronicles One Stack Mind Cathy Young Neocon Express A A R D V A R K World Climate Report Apartment 604 Yelling at the Windshield Kimdergarten/ ShrinkWrapped The Bear Cave X marks the blogspot CARRY ON AMERICA Jim Rose Kiril, The Mad Macedonian Signal 94 Pseudo-Polymath The International Libertarian Gates of Vienna California Sojourn The Liberty Papers Barcepundit A. Jacksonian Jon Swift Tim Maguire Three Sticks Asymmetric Dog Politics OregonGuy Little Miss Attila Buuuuurrrrning Hot AGENT BEDHEAD THE TYGRRRR EXPRESS David Harsanyi Snowflakes in Hell Earnest Iconoclast Eternity Road Musings of the GeekWithA.45 Total Survivalist Libertarian Rantfest Argue With Everyone Political Forum Nathan J. Winograd Assistant Village Idiot Parkway Rest Stop Grouchy Old Cripple Technicalities Coalition of the Swilling TigerHawk Mary Madigan Sad Old Goth Erica Sherman Joated Ezra Levant
![]() Blogroll Classical Values! Pssst! Wanna get on the Classical Values blogroll? Please send me an email and let me know, because although I try to keep up, sometimes I have trouble finding every last link.
Site Credits
|
|
I wish I could tie Krugman to a chair and force him to answer these questions, really answer them, rather than be allowed to answer evasively.
Same goes for Dan Rather and the fake documents. Same goes for... I could go on forever.
Anyway, great if limited fisking!