The Face Of America In Anbar
BoyswithStuffedPigRamadi - Michael Totten
Photo of Boys with a Stuffed Pig by Michael Totten © 2007

My friend Michael Totten has an article up, The Peace Corps With Muscle, that I have linked to several times in the comments here at Classical Values. So I thought it was time to do a front pager and look at how the war is going in what used to be one of the toughest neighborhoods in Iraq.

Now that major combat operations are finished almost everywhere in Iraq's Anbar Province, the United States Army and Marine Corps are more like a United Nations peacekeeping force with rules of engagement that allow them to kill if they have to. "We're like the Peace Corps with muscles," is how one soldier put it when I left with his unit at 4:00 in the morning to deliver food stuffs and toys to needy families in the countryside on the edge of the desert.
That is real progress. Will it hold? No one knows. However, it has been holding for some months now.

During this day that Michael reports on American forces in Ramadi were guarding an aid mission convoy.

The police trucks and Humvees rolled along at perhaps one mile an hour as women, children, and a few men emerged groggily from their homes and walked up to the convoy.

Iraqi police officers handed heavy bags of flour and rice to adults and gave out smaller packages to the children.

Not much fighting or excitement here. Except for the people who will be able to feed their families and hope for better times.
All I could do was take pictures and notes. It was an awkward moment. I felt dumb and also like an intruder for seeing humble people in moments of weakness at dawn in front of their houses.

Children swarmed the roads and fought their way to the sides of the trucks. The Iraqi police yelled at them as they handed out items. The Americans quietly provided security for everyone while this was happening.

So what are the odds of turning Iraq around? It is no longer the hopeless case it was nine months ago, but the odds are still long.
Iraq is a painful country. It hurts those who live there, and it hurts those who go there. It isn't the saddest place I've ever visited - Libya earns that dubious distinction. But it is the most distressing, not only because of the violence and horror almost everyone who lives there has experienced, and in many places still experiences, but because it's hard to shake the dreadful feeling that terrible forces are gearing up to punish the place even more.

Anbar Province, while broken by war, is sort of okay.

Michael has a few words to say about the "if it bleeds it leads" journalism in Iraq.
This is what it's like now in and just outside Ramadi. This mission is the kind of thing embedded journalists see, which is why most war correspondents embed somewhere else. Soldiers Hand Out Newspapers and Rice isn't much of a headline, and it's even less of a scoop. But this is the kind of work soldiers do now every day in what was recently the most violent place in Iraq.
From the comments Michael gives an estimate of the chances for holding Iraq together and turning Iraq into one of the better places in the Middle East. Not necessarily good. Just better than most.
Shaulie: do you have hope for the mission? Your Ramadi dispatches incline me to the former, but when you mention Baghdad you seem to incline to the latter.

Not a lot. Only a little.

I think of the mission mostly as damage control at this point.

It looks to me like the US and Iraq are screwed if we stay and more even screwed if we leave.

But I don't know what is going to happen. No one does. I give it a one-in-four shot, but that's a gut-feeling guess.

Iraq isn't quite as bad a place as it was, but it is still an emergency room case as a whole. We'll just have to wait and see what happens.

If anyone can "save" Iraq, Petraeus can because he knows what he is doing. If he can't pull it off, probably nobody can. If the Iraqis don't get their act together it doesn't matter how good Petraeus is at his job.

Michael also tells what it is like being on the ground in Iraq. It is a hard life. Michael and the soldiers will eventually go back to "the world" as we used to say in 'Nam. The people of Iraq will have to live there.

A soldier asks:

"What are you doing here in August anyway?" he said.

"A fine question," I said as I seriously wondered why I hadn't waited for October or even November. The heat in Iraq during the summer is enough to make a religious man rail against God. I'm baffled, frankly, at how human civilization began in a place so inhospitable to human beings. Someone, I forget who, compared facing the afternoon breeze to sticking a hair dryer in your face while pouring sand on your head. That pretty much says it. It is much worse than in a place like Arizona, for instance, because you can hardly catch a break from it unless you stay on base in one of the buildings.

Hell of a way to earn a living. Both for Michael and the soldiers.

If you like what you saw and read here from Michael go to his www site and put a few pennies in the tip jar. He does what he does on the dimes we send him.

Thanks Michael and God Bless you, our military, and the people of Iraq.

posted by Simon on 10.07.07 at 08:44 PM





TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://classicalvalues.com/cgi-bin/pings.cgi/5627






Comments

It's good to know that things are constantly improving in Ramadi, albeit slowly. When I left in February 27, I'd hoped the situation would continue to improve; we'd lost a lot of good Soldiers and Marines there in an effort to do so.

One of the biggest problems in Ramadi, and in Al Anbar is that the central Shia-dominated government in Baghdad won't support the Sunni security forces, so Sunnis who are stepping up to patrol their own streets and take over for US forces are being poorly treated, ill supplied if supplied at all, and often unpaid for months at a time unless US pressure is placed on the Shia's holding the purse strings. I really hope that things will change enough to allow Al Anbar Provine to continue to improve and not die on the vine becasue of a lack of true support form Baghdad.

I think that it will take the US working with local and regional governments to really make Iraq work on a town by town and city by city basis, then maybe the central government will be able to take on the national level tasks it needs to to keep Iraq a nation.

SFC SKI   ·  October 8, 2007 03:17 PM

Post a comment

You may use basic HTML for formatting.





Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)



October 2007
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 31      

ANCIENT (AND MODERN)
WORLD-WIDE CALENDAR


Search the Site


E-mail




Classics To Go

Classical Values PDA Link



Archives




Recent Entries



Links



Site Credits