March 06, 2004
Where have all the flowers gone?
Long time Kass-ing, I guess...
But here's another Kass quote which will not go away:
"Could the beauty of flowers depend on the fact that they will soon wither? . . . How deeply could one deathless ‘human’ being love another?"Is love conditioned upon death? I thought love was theoretically "eternal."
But I want to allow Kass as much latitude as possible -- and I do mean latitude, because in Chicago the flower season is short. Maybe even brutishly short. Californians, on the other hand, do not see the seasons quite the same way, and I'd be willing to bet are not as inclined to define the beauty of flowers based on their mortality.
Besides, I see a logical error in identifying mortality with flowers in order to "beautify" death. Plenty of ugly things also die, yet Kass would not cite them as arguments in favor of the beauty of mortality. Or would he? Guys like Kass are often inclined to factor anything that happens as favoring their arguments, so perhaps the death of more obnoxious life forms is also an argument in favor of mortality.
(I suspect he uses flowers as a selling point because they invoke a more predictable emotional response than say, the death of plague-infected rats.)
Continuing the Kass logic, however, let us try for a moment to imagine what an awful world it would be if flowers never died! Why, there'd be so many flowers, no one would think they were beautiful, right? (Tell that to the breeders of perrenial orchids!) Great works of art are not said to be mortal. Would, say, the Mona Lisa or the Pieta be "improved" if some nutcase like Laszlo Toth managed to destroy them? I can't see how.
The whole notion of placing limits on things by invoking nature and the ancients is problematic at best, because there are always other ways of seeing the same ideas.
Perhaps Mao knew what he was thinking when he announced, "Let a hundred flowers bloom!"
Maybe we need some slogans to really get this "mortal conservative" movement of neo-nihilism going....
All flowers must die!
Death is beautiful!
Immortality = immorality!
All good things must come to an end!
(And so on.....)
posted by Eric on 03.06.04 at 03:02 PM
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Where have all the flowers gone?:
Search the Site
Classics To Go
See more archives here
Old (Blogspot) archives
Why you might get more of what you try to stop
A knee sock jihad might be premature at this time
People Are Not Rational
No Biorobots For Japan
The Thorium Solution
Radiation Detector From A Digital Camera
This war of attrition is driving me bananas!
Attacking Christianity is one thing, but must they butcher geometry?
Are there trashy distinctions in freedom of expression?