protect us against discrimination!

No matter where I go or what I do, there's just no escaping discrimination in America.

I rode the subway in New York yesterday, and saw the following sign posted prominently in every car:

SubwayNY.jpg

I didn't have time to reflect much on the above (much less write a blog post) and was barely able to snap a photo just before I left the subway car. My very act of snapping the photo caused the people sitting under the sign to look up in alarm.

"I wanted a photo of that sign," I commented in the general direction of the alarmed eyes, which immediately began to scrutinize the suddenly-interesting sign as I exited.

Now that it's the next day, and I've returned home, I see that Time Magazine is reporting that Ayman al-Zawahiri nixed al Qaida's 2003 plan to release deadly cyanide gas in the New York subway.

It goes without saying that cyanide gas does not discriminate between employees and mere passengers.

Coincidentally, the felony assault law was passed the same year (2003) that the cyanide plan was jettisoned -- in response to incidents like this:

Michael Cifu, a train conductor, was working the Harlem Line of New York's Metro-North Commuter Train on Jan. 19, 2001. It was almost 6:30 p.m. when the train pulled from the Mount Vernon West station, just north of the Bronx and the last stop on the line. But on the return to Manhattan, he was told that a passenger was asleep in the second car from the end.

Cifu shook the man awake as he passed him on his way to the rear of the train. The man awoke agitated and possibly drunk. "I turn around and see the guy charging me with a hammer," Cifu, 47, recalls. The frightened conductor hid in the cab, but as he leaned out of the window to check on the man's whereabouts, the man struck him with the hammer. The blow opened a wound in his forehead that took 20 stitches to close. He still bears the scar.

Of course, the man accused of multiple stabbings in the New York subway earlier this week seems to have avoided stabbing MTA employees. Instead, he directed most of his wrath against tourists:
At 3:41 p.m., the authorities say, Mr. Alexis stabbed a 21-year-old tourist from Texas on a southbound C train in Harlem, saying later that the man was in his way.

About 12 hours later, the police said, Mr. Alexis stabbed a 30-year-old Brooklyn man on a subway platform at Rockefeller Center after the victim refused to give up his cellphone.

Then Mr. Alexis stabbed two students from Montreal, one 22 years old and the other 25, who were standing on a traffic island in Times Square, after he unsuccessfully tried to engage the two women in conversation, the police said.

He was arrested after witnesses to the last attack followed the assailant to a McDonald's in Times Square and called the police.

All four victims were recovering. "In all likelihood," Professor Levin said of the attacker, "he sought revenge for his miseries, not against any particular individual, but against an entire group of people — all New Yorkers, all Americans, all of humankind."

Another criminologist at Northeastern, James Alan Fox, said that sometimes there was method to the madness. "Most people who go on crime sprees like this don't necessarily attack randomly," he said. "It may look random — they may not be targets they know — but certain kinds of targets. Those are people who 'just snap,' but who have a longstanding grudge.

"The more random the event, the more likely it's a case of mental illness where the person is delusional in some way," Professor Fox said. "Alexis is a homeless man. There's a good possibility he is suffering from some undiagnosed mental disorders that play into his decision to attack and his decision whom to attack. Then, there's no pattern to victims except unfortunately for them being in the wrong place at the wrong time."

Well, at least he doesn't seem to attack transit employees or public officials!

Professor Fox's opinion that the man was homeless was contradicted in this earlier report. (More details about the suspect and his crimes here. It seems he listed a homeless shelter as his address, so he'd probably fit most people's definitions of "homeless" -- although I'm not sure that's the issue. His primary complaint is that people are watching him.)

The point is that society, in its infinite wisdom, has decided that transit employees are a protected category. Attacks on them are more serious than attacks on you.

You don't like it, who you gonna sue?


MORE: Here's a true story from the distant past. Back in the 1980s, a psychotic, obviously intoxicated man with bloodshot eyes entered my yard in Berkeley, where there was a wooden door removed from its hinges, waiting to be refinished. The man picked up the door and started throwing it around repeatedly in a manner I can fairly describe as irritating, offensive, and dangerous. (Anyone in the yard could have been severely injured.) When we told him that this was private property and he had to get out, we were completely ignored, as he was having too much fun with his tantrum. At that point, we decided that brandishing a gun might be the best way to change his mind. I will never forget how quickly this "crazy man" showed clear evidence of sanity as soon as he heard the semiautomatic pistol slide being ratcheted back. Jolted into reality (I guess that's the right word for self preservation), he ran from the yard. The police were never called, as we feared that we might be considered the criminals.

Ever since then, I have tended to believe that many of these so-called "mentally ill" and "homeless" people have a lot more common sense than the Harvard experts would have us believe.

posted by Eric on 06.18.06 at 08:18 AM





TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://classicalvalues.com/cgi-bin/pings.cgi/3731






Comments

Bravo. Good points all, and I liked the anecdote. You're making me want to own a gun.

Dennis   ·  June 18, 2006 11:05 AM

Great story at the end.

I am one of those types who is easily annoyed by blatant disrespect of my (and others) property as well as loud noises late at night.

I am quite often knocking on peoples doors to tell them that in case they hadnt realized it, its 2am on a Wednesday night and I can hear their stereo from 100 yards away with my windows closed. Ive yet to have anyone NOT comply with my request. It helps that Im rather large and scary looking.

When I tell people these stories, I usually get the reply "you should just call the cops" or "youre going to get shot one of these days". Its this mentality that causes people to be silent in the face of egregious public behavior.

People will do what they think they can get away with. In my experience, its not that they think they arent bothering anyone, its that they think that noone would dare confront them for being a complete ass.

In any case, your remarks bring to mind a great UK article I just read about taking personal responsibility for the behavior of others in your area rather than relying on 'papa government' to reslove absolutely ever minor conflict.

http://www.spiked-online.com/index.php?/site/article/388

Mick   ·  June 18, 2006 04:43 PM

Just remembered a specific story that illustrates this perfectly.

I was at a gas station filling up when I heard some 15 year old kid shouting. I look up to see him hanging out of the passenger window of a pickup truck verbally accosting people as they walked by. Shouting obscenities and whistling at one woman with a baby. And standing at the pickup was an adult male (presumeable the father) ignoring the whole thing.

After I was done filling up I had to walk by the pickup in order to get in and pay. The kid shouts to me "Hey you, Im looking for Willie Nelson! Have you seen Willie Nelson?" To which I reply, "What youre looking for is a fist in the mouth!"

The kid was stupefied. He sat there for a few seconds slack-jawed before he slid back into the truck and sat quietly until they left.

Good behavior is easy to instill/inspire in others if only there is the will to do so.

Mick   ·  June 18, 2006 04:52 PM

Dennis, as an emergency backup, it brings much peace of mind. (Bear in mind that during an actual emergency is a very poor time to buy one.)

Mick, you reminded me of a recent incident involving a SIXTH GRADE PROM thrown by a public school, which was disturbing neighbors with a live DJ playing rap music at concert hall pitch late at night. When a neighbor complained, a teacher rudely told her "These are just CHILDREN!" -- and acted as if the problem was with the neighbor. When I was in the sixth grade a prom was the furthest thing from my mind. The teachers are nuts, and they're raising a generation of vipers who accept no responsibility for anything. Well, where would they learn it? Certainly not from the teachers who throw proms for them and accept no responsibility.

Eric Scheie   ·  June 18, 2006 06:57 PM

I spent the weekend lifeguarding at two of my parents' properties and I became the enemy of a great number of children, and not a few adults. No one seems to understand why rules exist, and they consider me 'rude' and 'not nice' when I don't let them ignore the rules.

But nothing works as well as a little old-fashioned authority. I put a scare into a gang of teenagers who were violently abusing the playground equipment and embarrassed them in front of their girlfriends, and I think it had everything to do with the fact that they're not accustomed to being confronted by adults.

I can see in their faces that parents don't much like it when I raise my voice with their children, but so far they haven't argued.

Dennis   ·  June 18, 2006 10:43 PM

"These are just CHILDREN!"

Oh I've heard this a few times myself from parents! I had a Section 8 house (public subsidized rent) three doors down from me that had seven children who would run wild screaming until 11 at night. Im talking from ages 11 down to 4! When I confronted the mother, I was told that "this is everyones neighborhood not just yours, and there aint no playground" and I "shouldn't even be talking to these childrens, cause theys just BABIES!"

You can imagine my ire at being told whos neighborhood belongs to whom, not only when Im paying property taxes to 'educate' these little animals, but taxes that also pay for this 400lb Welfare Queens house, food and whatever else.

This one I did end up having to call the cops though. I've got a list a mile long, but for the most part, a stern word was so shocking to the recipient that it achieved the desired ressults.

I dont think there are many societal ills that cant be cured by more beatings of smart mouthed kids.


Mick   ·  June 18, 2006 11:03 PM

question of how to handle this situation ; my 13 yr old daughter went to the playground and at the playground there was a group of boys playing a basketball game these groups consisted of a religous one and the local ones . one of the local boys had asked my daughter to play when next thing we knew was the religous group said she can not play withthem because she was a girl . one of the religous boys even said to a local boy and qoute " if we play with tehm , they think we go to far with them" this all happened on the schoolyard where my children attend and yes i pay taxes for where the religous group has their own school in the end my daughter was hurt and not happy so after she had come to me and a few others she walked back outside from the school and told all the boys that she was playing no matter what . the one religous group left and all the locals were upset that this had occurred the school board was informed of this but have not go tan answer from them yet so my question i am getting alot of pressure to write letters and contact media of this incident and i am looking for any advice anyone can give me . it would greatly be appreciated thank you

holly   ·  June 27, 2006 09:35 PM


December 2006
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
          1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31            

ANCIENT (AND MODERN)
WORLD-WIDE CALENDAR


Search the Site


E-mail




Classics To Go

Classical Values PDA Link



Archives




Recent Entries



Links



Site Credits