Beaten down by change?

I don't like to correct people, and it isn't my job to do it here, but I hate it when the plain meaning of expressions is changed simply because the historical source of the expression has been forgotten.

Recently I was startled to hear the term "whipping boy" applied to an overworked employee whose boss was a hard-driving taskmaster.

That is not the meaning of the term "whipping boy." I don't care how abusive a boss might be (or how masochistic an employee), a whipping boy is not merely someone who is punished or abused; he must take punishment on behalf of another -- and not at the hands of that person (i.e. a scapegoat).

This is a very old concept, and a historically interesting one. Wondering whether it might be falling into misuse (like the word "decimate" -- which once meant a ten percent destruction of forces), it didn't take me long to find examples.

I realize that leftists consider Bush an oppressive tyrant, but that does not make his alleged victims his "whipping boy" -- despite the insistence of this post:

Airstrikes on Iraqi weddings so Bush can appear to have a plan? How many people have to die for Bush to get elected? Or have the Iraqi people just become Bush's whipping boy when he gets upset? For their sake we ought to hope Bush does better in tonight's debate.
Look, this isn't about politics. It's one thing to hate Bush, but if you're going to call someone or some group a "whipping boy," just use the term accurately. (I could see calling John Bolton "Bush's UN whipping boy," for example.)

I hate to dwell on this, but I'm having fun with my "whipping boy" hate fest, so here's another hideous example (this one involving the elder Bush):

In the interest in keeping the world's informational databases accurate and safe, Willie Horton was the Massachussetts-furloughed murderer who subsequently became George Bush's whipping boy during his presidential run against Dukakis.
Wrong. Willie Horton was not the elder Bush's "whipping boy" any more than the Iraqi people are the younger Bush's whipping boy. Willie Horton did not receive blame for anything Bush did, nor was he punished -- literally or figuratively -- for any of Bush's errors.

The term "whipping boy" is historical, and it is based on real boys whose function it was to be punished in place of misbehaving princes:

It seems an odd notion to us now that a royal court would have kept a child for the purpose of beating him when the crown prince did wrong. That's just what did happen though. Whipping Boy was an established position at the English court during the Tudor and Stuart monarchies of the 15th and 16th centuries. This may not have been quite as bad as it sounds. The whipping boys weren't hapless street urchins living a life of torment, but high-born companions to the royal princes. They were educated with the princes and shared many of the privileges of royalty. The downside was that, if the prince did wrong, the whipping boy was punished. It was considered a form of punishment to the prince that someone he cared about was made to suffer.
"Whipping boy" is a good, solid, traditional term, but it involves knowing a little bit about history -- something in short supply these days.

I think I have beaten this to death, and I hope no one objects too much to my historical defensiveness. It is beneath my dignity to be a whipping boy's whipping boy.

(I'd rather catch flak for defending ovaries, although that brings to mind another troublesome expression -- and I do not mean "ovarian whipping boy" . . . )

posted by Eric on 07.03.06 at 07:49 AM





TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://classicalvalues.com/cgi-bin/pings.cgi/3786






Comments

Thanks for the clarifying post!

Justin Case's Former Personal Whipping Boy   ·  July 3, 2006 11:15 PM


March 2007
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
        1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31

ANCIENT (AND MODERN)
WORLD-WIDE CALENDAR


Search the Site


E-mail




Classics To Go

Classical Values PDA Link



Archives




Recent Entries



Links



Site Credits