Bad logic opens the gateway to hell

The stuff that passes for science these days is unbelievable.

Here's a news report about a "study" which (so it is claimed) shows that violent video games make young men smoke marijuana!

"Parents have been told the message that violent video games and violent media in general can influence the likelihood that their kids will be aggressive," Dr. Sonya S. Brady told Reuters Health. "What this study suggests is that they might increase any type of risk-taking behaviour."

According to the report in the Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, playing a violent game caused young men's blood pressure to increase, and appeared to have a greater effect on those that came from violent homes or communities. No matter what background each male had, the researchers found that playing a violent game made the young men in the study less cooperative and more competitive in completing tasks with another person.

After playing one of the games, the males participating in the study were shown a scenario of a teacher telling his class that he suspects some students have cheated, but also that he is proud of those who did well. The teacher then asks a boy called Billy to stay behind after class so that he may speak with him. Participants were then asked to put themselves in Billy's position. When asked how likely it was that the teacher was going to accuse them of cheating, those participants who had been playing Grand Theft Auto were more likely think they would be accused.

Wow. If that's science, I should apply for a government grant, because I think can prove that blogging can also raise blood pressure!

Who knows, there might be an association between blogging and drinking. Or even pot-smoking!

After I finished laughing out loud, I tried to find out more about the study's "conclusions":

In the second report, Sonya S. Brady, a postdoctorate fellow in psychiatry at the University of California, San Francisco, and a colleague tested the reaction of 100 college men, 18 to 21 years old, to two video games,Grand Theft Auto III or The Simpsons: Hit and Run.

"When the men played the more violent video game, Grand Theft Auto, versus the less violent video game, The Simpsons: Hit and Run, they had greater increases in blood pressure, and those who played Grand Theft Auto had more negative emotions and hostile feelings," Brady said.

In addition, those who played Grand Theft Auto had more permissive attitudes about alcohol and marijuana use, Brady said. "Video games cannot only influence aggression, but might also influence attitudes toward risk-taking behavior," she said.

Elsewhere, the games are even called a "gateway drug!"
New research conducted by Dr. Sonya Brady at the University of California, San Francisco and Professor Karen Matthews at the University of Pittsburgh, recently published in the Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine (April 2006), suggests that violent video games can be gateway drugs of sorts in that they can lead to "permissive attitudes toward violence, alcohol use, marijuana use, and sexual activity without condom use."
At the risk of being redundant, CORRELATION IS NOT CAUSATION!!

(The logical error is called post hoc ergo propter hoc.)

Here's my ironclad scientific conclusion: the more I'm exposed to bad logic, the higher my blood pressure is raised, the more negative and hostile my feelings become, and the more permissive my attitudes about alcohol and marijuana use (to say nothing of heroin use) become!

I suspect that this is a gateway which forces me to write blog posts, which are truly the gateway to utter ruin.

Clearly, more studies are needed.

So where's my gummint grant?

posted by Eric on 04.12.06 at 11:32 AM





TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://classicalvalues.com/cgi-bin/pings.cgi/3503






Comments

Couldn't agree more with how ridiculous this is... although I will say that smoking weed does make gaming more fun, and vice versa. Then again smoking weed makes LOTS of things more fun, and vice versa. Er... uh... so I've heard.

Harkonnendog   ·  April 12, 2006 08:40 PM

This "study" is absurd. Ask any gamer that has spent more than a few hours on a racing or time trial-type racing game (such as Simpsons: Hit and Run) and they will most likely agree that no video games are more frustrating and hostility-inducing than these. E.g. "Crap I didn't get the power slide 'just' right on that turn, RESTART" (repeat dozens of times and pretty soon your keyboard is snapped in half over your knee and seeing all those keys fly through the air is the most glorious sight to behold. GTA, as violent as it sounds, beating a hooker with a baseball bat, and taking that whore's money is relaxing in a way. "I need this more than you, I think" I smile, and there are plenty of studies relating smiling to a healthy living.

As for the marijuana; as long as I am surrounded by my college-age peers who just are so excited to funnel beer after beer down there throats till the vomit, pass out, get arrested, get injured, etc, marijuana is a welcome relief to egos that inflate exponentially with alcohol consumption. ...I forgot where I was going with that...

Mark   ·  April 12, 2006 09:54 PM

I was joking around the other day about violent video games being a "gateway drug." Apparently, somebody took me too seriously.

Hart704   ·  April 13, 2006 06:39 AM

That explains why my cart keeps refusing to push my mule around town.

Beck   ·  April 13, 2006 09:10 AM

Of course, it goes without saying that consumption of Cheetos is known to lead to consumption of marijuana. That's just plain common sense.

Beck   ·  April 13, 2006 09:13 AM

John, much as I hate to disagree with you, you're dead wrong on this one. It's marijuana which leads to Cheetos, NOT the other way around!

And Cheetos can kill!

Eric Scheie   ·  April 13, 2006 09:59 AM


March 2007
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
        1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31

ANCIENT (AND MODERN)
WORLD-WIDE CALENDAR


Search the Site


E-mail




Classics To Go

Classical Values PDA Link



Archives




Recent Entries



Links



Site Credits